"I've got to tell you, I'm kind of torn," he continued, adding that there's a clear bull and bear thesis for the stock.
But Instacart's turn toward profitability means its growth has slowed, Cramer added.
Its revenue increased 15% in the second quarter, down from 40% growth in the year-earlier period, CNBC reported.
Cramer said he wonders whether there's some "window dressing" in the company's pivot to profitability and if it can sustain growth like it did before the IPO.
"Instacart's got a good brand name, but it's hard for me to get super excited about it at these levels," Cramer said.
Persons:
CNBC's Jim Cramer, he's, Cramer, I've, Instacart's, you've
Organizations:
CNBC
Locations:
Tuesday's, U.S